@
Erin KissaneThe Engine Room report is a well-meaning effort. But as you note, the “majority world” refers to
“places and populations that have historically been colonized and underdeveloped by the ruling classes of the "Global North." Not incidentally, these are also the places and populations from which the Global North extracts both the raw materials and the crushing physical and cognitive labor that our networks and increasingly voracious software systems require.”
As you hint in your second sentence, #
colonialism and #
imperialism were not something that simply happened in the past, they are ongoing processes of exploitation. The peoples of the #
GlobalSouth, in their myriad ways, are working to redress the injustices and the imbalances of colonialism and imperialism, practiced by the #
GlobalNorth. What we see on social media (even the alternative social media) is just a reflection of those injustices and imbalances.
The best path to a more egalitarian social media, whether centralized or federated or whatever, is through the struggle for the overthrow of colonialism and imperialism. For obvious reasons, the global north is deeply invested in crushing such struggles. If it ceases to exploit the global south, the global north ceases to exist (in its present dominant form). Therefore, the most resilient and meaningful social media will be shaped by the antagonistic relation between the global north and the global south.
But reports like this will not, and cannot, point this out. Ultimately, funding for these initiatives comes from non-governmental organizations that are a part of the global north establishment, and have a stake in maintaining the dominance of the global north.
Within that structural limitation, the Engine Room report does a decent job. But because of that limitation, its recommendations amount to nothing more than a band aid.
I am not discouraging such efforts, merely pointing out that they will have built-in limitations precisely because they come from structures within the global north establishment.